Saturday, August 1, 2015

Matrimony Month: Arthur, Coming To America and Overboard: Identity Porn in 80s Romance



The dawn of the 80s meant something new and fresh was in the air.  Marriage and romance had to be treated differently; we lived in a world where women had joined the workforce, where girls were told that they could be anyone, do anything, as they were raised.  This resulted in comedies about divorced people finding themselves; movies about second chances and balancing career and romance.  The schism between Mr. Mom and Heartburn is endemic of the decade they belonged to; everyone was suffering from growing pains, and everyone was trying to figure out how to adjust to the new international moral code.

Is it surprising that the pursuit of love turned away from marriage and toward different aspects of love?  The foreboding inherent in divorce dramas like Kramer vs Kramer gave way to a wave of fluffy teen romances like Pretty in Pink and Valley Girl, to soft romantic fantasy like Splash and Mannequin, and to complicated romantic and erotic psychodramas like 9 ½ Weeks and Wild Orchid.

Is it any wonder that the more marital-minded romances of the 80s had something of an identity crises going on and that the question ‘for love or money?’ could not have been asked more loudly during the Gordon Gecko years?




Arthur lead the pack into the 80s, was one of the highest grossing movies of the early 80s, and showed off the schism between the haves and have nots of the me decade.   Scheduled to marry a pampered heiress, Arthur finds himself on a drunken walk on the poor side, considering becoming someone he’s not – a sober, committed adult with a job – when he helps a shoplifting waitress out of a jam and defies his trustee’s wishes.   They later settle into a marriage that’s complicated by outside forces; they get along so well that the only thing that ever blocks the purity of their togetherness is those who keep threatening Arthur’s family fortune.  Linda is the best thing about the movies; she has dignity and one can understand why Hobson finds her suitable match for Arthur.  Perhaps that’s why it’s impossible to relate to Linda and Arthur as a married couple in Arthur 2: the money, in spite of all protest, seems to be all that matters.



Akeem Joffer, the crown prince of Coming to America, pretends to be poor and moves to New York to find a wife, and eventually discovers his soulmate in the idealist daughter of a fast food restaurant owner.  Here it’s the children who have integrity, pride, and smarts; the adults are corner-cutters, tradition-clinging and stubborn.  Marriage is portrayed as something suited to people who value so much more out of one another than obedience, an admirable idea that’s leavened with great dollops of iconic humor.  One can envision Lisa and Akeem living on happily years after the movie concludes because it builds their bond beyond the light facile mistaken identity plot from whence it springs.



If Akeem is looking for an equal, Dean Proffitt of “Overboard” is looking for a woman willing to defrost his refrigerator, take care of his ramshackle house and raise his wayward and somewhat neglected sons.  He gets the chance when an heiress who hates his carpentry falls off of her yacht and washes ashore sans memory.  Dean decides this is a great excuse for him to take his revenge against Annie and basically makes her his slave under the pretense of her being his long-lost wife.  But a genuine marriage blossoms out of this backward commitment, with Annie helping the kids, fixing the house, and encouraging Dean to take the plunge and put together his own mini golf course.


That Annie and Dean actually manage to fall in love and stay together after their multiple lies are brought to light is an act of sitcom artifice;  no healthy marriage would ever survive what they go through, which is probably why it’s become such a fond and fluffy, if inconsequential bit of 80s romance.  Fantasies about star-crossed lovers and dancing in dive bars somehow seem sane when you have Kurt Russell and Goldie Hawn leading the way, and eventually they learn the meaning of mutual respect via heavy application of a firehose.  At least they can help each other reach their dreams, simple but fulfilling so they are.

No comments:

Post a Comment